Across the United States more than 2,700 companies are collecting state income taxes from hundreds of thousands of workers – and are keeping the money with the states’ approval, says an eye-opening report published on Thursday.
The report from Good Jobs First, a nonprofit taxpayer watchdog organization funded by Ford, Surdna and other major foundations, identifies 16 states that let companies divert some or all of the state income taxes deducted from workers’ paychecks. None of the states requires notifying the workers, whose withholdings are treated as taxes they paid.
General Electric, Goldman Sachs, Procter & Gamble, Chrysler, Ford, General Motors and AMC Theatres enjoy deals to keep state taxes deducted from their workers’ paychecks, the report shows. Foreign companies also enjoy such arrangements, including Electrolux, Nissan, Toyota and a host of Canadian, Japanese and European banks, Good Jobs First says.
Why do state governments do this? Public records show that large companies often pay little or no state income tax in states where they have large operations, as this column has documented. Some companies get discounts on property, sales and other taxes. So how to provide even more subsidies without writing a check? Simple. Let corporations keep the state income taxes deducted from their workers’ paychecks for up to 25 years.
It was not always this way. Letting companies keep their workers’ state taxes apparently began in Kentucky two decades ago as a way to retain jobs.
Last July when I wrote about six big companies that pocket Illinois state taxes I knew there was more to this. But I had no idea how pervasive these diversions were until I read an advance copy of the 39-page report by Good Jobs First.
CORPORATE SOCIALISM
Deals cut with the states over the past two decades diverted $5.5 billion from public purposes to private gain, the report says. Close to $700 million more was diverted last year, Good Jobs First estimates.
New Jersey approved $73.2 million in new deals in 2011 on top of $178 million diverted that year alone under previous deals. I calculate that at nearly $80 per household in corporate welfare based on New Jersey’s 3.1 million households.
These deals typify corporate socialism, in which business gains are privatized and costs socialized. They also mean government picks winners and losers, interfering with competitive markets. Leaders in both parties embrace these giveaways because they draw campaign donations from corporate interests and votes from people who do not understand that they are subsidizing huge companies.
Michael Press, a Connecticut consultant on tax incentives, says such deals, however troubling, are an inevitable result of the U.S. Constitution setting up competition between the states.
“In an ideal world we would not provide any corporate subsidies,” Press told me. “It looks like corruption. But if you do it right, if you only target those companies whose behavior you change to create jobs or keep jobs in your state then these targeted temporary arrangements are cheaper – much cheaper – and can be more effective than an overall reduction in tax rates.”
The mission of Good Jobs First is making economic development subsidies accountable and effective. In years of working with their data I have always found it sound. While Greg LeRoy, Good Jobs First’s founder, has rooted out all sorts of hidden subsidies over the years, he emphasizes that he is not inherently hostile to them, only to secrecy, waste and what he calls job piracy and job blackmail.
“Job piracy” occurs when one state diverts taxes to lure an employer across state lines. AMC Entertainmentannounced a deal last year to move its corporate headquarters from Kansas City, Mo., to a nearby Kansas suburb. In return, Good Jobs First said, Kansas will let the multiplex chain keep $47 million of state income taxes withheld from its workers’ paychecks, a drain on public finances that did not create any jobs, but does enrich the Wall Street firms that own AMC including arms of J. P. Morgan, Apollo Management, Bain Capital and the Carlyle Group. AMC declined to answer my questions.
“Job blackmail” occurs when a company threatens to close a plant unless it gets tax money.
In Illinois, the law requires companies to threaten to leave before they can keep taxes withheld from paychecks. Motorola Mobility, now being acquired by Google; the truck maker Navistar; the German manufacturer Continental Tire, and three auto makers – Chrysler, Ford and Mitsubishi – get to keep $346.8 in taxes over 10 years because they threatened to leave Illinois. Navistar can pocket $62.1 million even if it fires a quarter of its Illinois workforce, its contract shows. A recent deal gives Sears $150 million, Good Jobs First reported.
PROMISES OF JOBS
Promising to retain jobs can be lucrative. General Electric invested $126 million updating part of its Ohio operations. In return, GE gets a tax credit equal to $115.3 million of its worker taxes, recovering 92 percent of its investment. A sweet deal for GE, but not its competitors.
Gary Sheffer, GE’s top spokesman, said the company told its workers about the deal. In all, he said, GE is investing around $300 million in Ohio and “the resulting taxes the state will receive will far exceed the tax credits provided to GE.”
That response, I think, misses the point – GE should pay its own bills without taking welfare.
Many figures in the Good Jobs First report are from disclosure reports some states make. Others come from news accounts and company announcements.
Total revenue losses are higher than the report states. First, some states hide the costs. Phil Mattera, the research director at Good Jobs First, said he lists the cost as zero for states that hide the numbers.
Good Jobs First wants to end these diversions, but failing that recommends mandatory disclosure to the workers as the first reform. I concur. It’s the first step in ending corporate welfare as we know it.
This Year Potential GOP Presidential Candidate Donald Trump Has Revealed Not Only To American Citizens But To The Global Community Something Very Negative, very Ugly About The Republican Party, i.e., GOP.
Mr. Trump's Actions & Apparent Racist Rantings Against Black People And Chinese People, Has Indeed Revealed The GOP's Most Vulnerable Political Faults.
1)The GOP Appears To Despise Or Show Very Little Interest In Real Diversity. Especially As It Relates To Working With Or Helping People Of Color, i.e., Mainly Black People.
2) The GOP Also Appears To Care More About Protecting Greedy Corporate Titans Than Fighting For Their Constituents.
Unless Of Course Those Constituents Are Billionaires & Millionaires.
But If You Are A Middle Class & Lower Income Citizen Take A Hike!!
At One Time I Thought That The GOP Had Returned To Its Former Roots.
You Know Like When It Welcomed With Open Arms Thousands Of Black Voters.
The GOP Appears No Longer To Be A Bastion For Racial Equality As It Was In The 50's & 60's.
Instead Today It Appears To Proudly Support Ideals Of The Klu Klux Klan.
Much More So In The Southern States/ Southeastern Region Of This Country.
At One Time In American History It Was The Democratic Party That Hated Black People.
Now Its The Republican Party. (Or Appears To Be)
Does This Mean I Will NO Longer Support Republican/ GOP Candidates Again?
To The Contrary!
As An Independent Registered Voter Who Still Believes In Bi-Partisan Leadership, I Will Continue To Support Republican Leaders Who Actually Deserve My Vote.
Ex: Pat McCrory Of North Carolina.
However NOT At The Expense Of Hurting The Entire American Black Community!!!
How Sad That So Many Voters Were Tricked Last November.
In 2010 The GOP Ran On A Platform Of Job Creation & Common Sense Reforms.
However After Winning A Historic Election, They Have ONLY Demonstrated Interest In Getting Rid Of Pres. Obama By ANY Means Necessary!
Even If It Means Via Blatant Lies, Racism Or Death!
As It Relates To Jobs, GOP Lawmakers Seem To Only Be Interested In Killing Jobs Via Their Fake Deficit Reduction Budget.
Since the election of Barack Obama, the Republican Party has proved that one of its central intellectual arguments was right all along. They have long claimed that evolution is a myth believed in only by whiny liberals -- and it turns out they were onto something. Every six months, the Republican Party venerates a new hero, and each time it is somebody further back on the evolutionary scale.
Sarah Palin told cheering rallies that her message to the world was: "We'll put a boot in your ass, it's the American way!" -- but that wasn't enough. So they found Michele Bachmann, who said darkly it was an "interesting coincidence" that swine flu only breaks out under Democratic presidents, claims the message of The Lion King is "I'm better at what I do because I'm gay," and argues "there isn't even one study that can be produced that shows carbon dioxide is a harmful gas."
That wasn't enough. I half-expected the next contender to be a lung-fish draped in the Stars and Stripes. But it wasn't anything so sophisticated. Enter stage (far) right Donald Trump, the bewigged billionaire who has filled America with phallic symbols and plastered his name across more surfaces than the average Central Asian dictator. A survey suggests he is the most popular candidate among Republican voters. It's not hard to see why.
Trump is every trend in Republican politics over the past thirty-five years taken to its logical conclusion. He is the Republican id, finally entirely unleashed from all restraint and all reality.
The first trend is towards naked imperialism. On Libya, he says: "I would go in and take the oil... I would take the oil and stop this baby stuff." On Iraq, he says: "We stay there, and we take the oil... In the old days, when you have a war and you win, that nation's yours." It is a view that the world is essentially America's property, inconveniently inhabited by foreigners squatting over oil-fields. Trump says America needs to "stop what's going on in the world. The world is just destroying our country. These other countries are sapping our strength." The U.S. must have full spectrum dominance. In this respect, he is simply an honest George W. Bush.
The second trend is towards dog-whistle prejudice -- pitched just high enough for frightened white Republicans to hear it. Trump made it a central issue to suggest Obama wasn't born in America (and therefore was occupying the White House illegally) -- even though this conspiracy theory had long since been proven to be as credible as the people who claim Paul McCartney was killed in 1969 and replaced with an imposter. Trump said nobody "ever comes forward" to say they knew Obama as a child in Hawaii. When lots of people pointed out they knew Obama as a child, Trump ridiculed the idea they could remember that far back. Then he said he'd "heard" the birth certificate said Obama was Muslim. When it was released saying no such thing, Trump said: "I'm very proud of myself."
The Republican primary voters heard the message right -- the black guy is foreign. He's not one of us. Trump responded to these charges by saying: "I've always had a great relationship with the blacks."
The third trend is towards raw worship of wealth as an end in itself -- and exempting them from all social responsibility. Trump is wealthy because his father left him a large business, and since then companies with his name on them have crashed into bankruptcy four times. In 1990, the Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Clay Johnson studied the Trump accounts and claimed that while Trump claimed to be worth $1.4bn, he was actually worth -$600m. That is, he owed $600m more than he owned. You and I were worth more than him.
Johnson says that in fact most of Trump's apparent fortune comes from "stiffing his creditors" and from government subsidies and favours for his projects -- which followed large donations to the campaigns of both parties, sometimes in the very same contest. Trump denies these charges and presents himself as an entrepreneur "of genius."
Yet for the Republican Party, the accumulation of money is proof in itself of virtue, however it was acquired. The richest 1 percent pay for the party's campaigns, and the party in turn serves their interests entirely. The most glaring example is that they have simply exempted many of the rich from taxes. Johnson studied four of Trump's recent tax returns, and found he legally paid no taxes in two of them. In America today, a janitor can pay more income tax than Donald Trump -- and the Republicans regard that not as a source of shame, but of pride.
How are these tax exemptions for the super-rich paid for? Here's one example. The Republican budget that just passed through the House slashed funding to help premature babies to survive. The rich riot while the poor shrivel. Trump offers the ultimate symbol of this -- he won't even shake hands with any ordinary Americans out on the stump, because "you catch all sorts of things" from them. Yes: the Republican front-runner is a billionaire who literally won't touch the poor or middle class.
The fourth trend is to insist that any fact inconvenient to your world-view either doesn't exist, or can be overcome by pure willpower. Soon, the U.S. will have to extend its debt ceiling -- the amount of money the government is allowed to borrow - or it will default on its debt. Virtually every economist in the world says this would cause another global economic crash. Trump snaps back: "What do economists know? Most of them aren't very smart."
Confront the Republicans with any long-term social or economic problem, and they have one response: it would go away if only we insisted on our assumptions more aggressively. So Trump says "it's so easy" to deal with rising oil prices. He says he would call in OPEC, the cartel of oil-producing nations, as if they were contestants on his show 'The Apprentice', and declare: "I'm going to look them in the eye and say 'Fellows, you've had your fun. Your fun is over.'... It's so easy. It's all about the messenger." It's the same, he says, with China. He will order them to stop manipulating their currency. When he was told they have some leverage over the US, he snapped: "They have some of our debt. Big deal. It's a very small number relative to the world, OK?"
This is what the Republican core vote wants to be told. The writer Matthew Yglesias calls it "the Green Lantern Theory of Geopolitics." It's named after the Marvel comics superhero the Green Lantern, who can only use his superpowers when he "overcomes fear" and shows confidence -- and then he can do anything. This is Trump's view. The whiny world simply needs to be bullied into submission by a more assertive America -- or the world can be fired and he'll find a better one.
Trump probably won't become the Republican nominee, but it won't be because most Republicans reject his premises. No: it will be because he states these arguments too crudely for mass public consumption. He takes the underlying whispered dogmas of the Reagan, Bush and Tea Party years and shrieks them through a megaphone. The nominee will share similar ideas, but express them more subtly.
In case you think these ideas are marginal to the party, remember -- it has united behind the budget plan of Wisconsin Representative Paul Ryan. It's simple: it halves taxes on the richest 1 percent and ends all taxes on corporate income, dividends and inheritance. It pays for it by slashing spending on food stamps, healthcare for the poor and the elderly, and basic services. It aims to return the US to the spending levels of the 1920s -- and while Ryan frames it as a response to the deficit, it would actually increase it according to the independent Center for Budget and Policy Priorities. Ryan says "the reason I got involved in public service" was because he read the writings of Ayn Rand, which describe the poor as "parasites" who must "perish", and are best summarized by the title of one of her books: 'The Virtue of Selfishness.'
The tragedy is that Obama needs serious opposition -- but not from this direction. In reality, he is funded by similar destructive corporate interests, and has only been a few notches closer to sanity than these people. But faced with such overt lunacy, he seems like he is serving the bottom 99 percent of Americans much more than he really is.
The Republican Party today isn't even dominated by market fundamentalism. This is a crude Nietzsheanism, dedicating to exalting the rich as an overclass and dismissing the rest. So who should be the Republican nominee? I hear the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse were considering running -- but they are facing primary challenges from the Tea Party for being way too mild-mannered.
Looks Like A Tough Political Showdown Between Pres. Obama & GOP Leaders Over Tax Breaks & Subsidies Is Headed Our Way.
You See The GOP Wants To Keep Throwing Money At Big Oil Companies In The Form Of Tax Subsidies In Exchange For BIG Campaign Checks From Oil Company Lobbyists.
President Obama On The Other Hand Wants To Cut Off Those Unfair Tax Subsidies & Tax Breaks.
In Fact GOP Lawmakers On Capitol Hill May Even Attempt To Use The Debt Ceiling As A Bribe Against Stopping Those Unfair Tax Subsidies To Big Oil Companies.
Excuse Me But Aren't Bribes What The GOP Accused Democrats Of Back In 2009 & 2010???
This Brutal Showdown Among Both Democrat & GOP Leaders Reveals One Of The Reasons Why Key GOP Lawmakers Are Trying To Kick Pres. Obama Out Of The Oval Office.
Can You Say: "The GOP Is More Likely Than Not As It Relates To Being Responsible For American Gas Price Gouging??"
That's Right!
It Appears As If The Republican Party Is Contributing To America's Current High Gasoline Prices, Yet NONE Of Them Want To Stop Giving Big Oil Companies Huge Tax Subsidies & Tax Breaks!
Just Another Logical Reason To VOTE OBAMA IN 2012!!
President Obama repeated his call Tuesday for an end to $4 billion in oil industry tax breaks as gas prices approach $4 a gallon and after a top lawmaker indicated a possible shift in Republican policy.
In a letter to congressional leaders, the president said the oil industry is profitable enough without the tax incentives and that the money should be spent on alternative energy sources and conservation.
"CEOs of the major oil companies have made it clear that high oil prices provide more than enough profit motive to invest in domestic production without special tax breaks," said Obama. "As we work together to reduce our deficits, we simply can't afford these wasteful subsidies."
This week those profits are going to be front and center. BP (BP) is expected to report earnings on Wednesday. Exxon (XOM, Fortune 500) is slated to announce its results on Thursday. Some analysts expect the company's profits to jump 50% from last year. Chevron (CVX, Fortune 500) is scheduled to make its earnings announcement on Friday.
The oil industry and many of its supporters in Congress have long argued that the tax breaks encourage domestic oil production and provide jobs for millions of Americans. Republicans in particular have resisted efforts to eliminate these tax breaks, something many Democrats have been trying to do since at least 2008.
But on Monday night, Speaker of the House John Boehner indicated he might be open to taking some of those breaks off the table.
Drill baby drill won't lower gas prices "I don't think the big oil companies need to have the oil depletion allowances, but for small, independent oil and gas producers, if they didn't have this, there'd be even less exploration in America than there is today," Boehner said on ABC's World News Tonight. "It's certainly something we need to be looking at."
Depletion allowances let oil companies treat the oil in the ground as capital equipment, and they can write off a certain percentage for each barrel that comes out.
On Tuesday the speaker appeared to backtrack from those comments, with an aid telling CNN that "what the President has suggested so far would simply raise taxes and increase the price at the pump."
Nonetheless, Obama took the chance to pounce, saying in his letter that he was "heartened that Speaker Boehner yesterday expressed openness to eliminating these tax subsidies."
This all comes as the price of gasoline surges above $4 a gallon in many states, making it increasingly difficult politically to defend Big Oil.
As gas prices approach their record highs set in 2008 they are threatening to derail the nation's nascent economic recovery.
The tax breaks in question The Obama administration is targeting nine tax breaks, according to a paper from the left-leaning Center for American Progress. Four account for the lion's share of the money:
Domestic manufacturing tax deduction: This is the largest single tax break, and would save over $1.7 billion a year if eliminated.
The tax deduction, passed in 2004, is designed to keep factories in the United States. Companies that manufacture here can deduct 9% of their income from operations that are attributed to domestic production.
But some question if that incentive is really appropriate for oil companies. "What are they going to do, move the oil field to the North Sea," said one staffer at the Center for American Progress said in an interview earlier this year.
No, but higher costs in the United States may make them move the drill rigs to the North Sea or some other place.
Eliminating the tax breaks "would actually discourage new energy projects and new hiring in one of the nation's most dependable job-creating industries," the American Petroleum Institute said in a statement at the time, noting the industry currently supports over 9 million jobs.
The percentage depletion allowance: This lets oil companies deduct about 15% of the money generated from a well from its taxes. Eliminating it would save about $1 billion a year.
The deduction essentially lets oil companies treat oil in the ground as capital equipment. For any industry, the value of that equipment can be written down each year.
But critics say oil in the ground is not capital equipment, but a national resource that the oil companies are simply using for their own profit.
The foreign tax credit: This provision gives companies a credit for any taxes they pay to other countries. Altering this tax credit would save about $850 million a year.
Foreign governments can collect money from oil companies through royalties -- fees for depleting their national resources -- and income taxes.
A royalty would be deducted as a cost of doing business, and would likely shave about 30% off a company's tax bill. Categorized as income tax, it is 100% deductible.
Foreign governments long ago grew wise to the U.S. tax code. To reduce costs for everyone involved and attract business, they agreed to call some royalties income taxes, allowing oil companies to take the 100% deduction on a bigger slice of their bill.
Intangible drilling costs: This lets the industry write off about $780 million a year for things like wages, fuel, repairs and hauling costs.
All industries get to write off the costs of doing business, but they must take it over the life of an investment. The oil industry gets to take the drilling credit in the first year.
Whether U.S. companies are drowning in high taxes or artful exploiters of loopholes is at the center of a debate over reforming corporate taxes.
Corporate America and Republicans often point to the United States as having among the highest tax rates in the world at about 35 percent, saying it makes the country less competitive and drives jobs overseas.
The Obama administration has acknowledged the need to overhaul the complex and confusing corporate tax code and agreed the top statutory rate is too high.
But administration officials say the 35 percent figure overstates U.S. companies' disadvantage once deductions and other breaks bring their "effective" tax rate much lower.
"Our tax system has not kept pace with the rest of the world," John Engler, the former Republican governor who heads up the Business Roundtable, a group of chief executives from the biggest U.S. companies.
The group of heavyweights like Verizon Communications and American Express Co. released a comparison of effective tax rates on Thursday that it said showed companies still pay more than their global peers.
The Business Roundtable-funded study, by corporate accountants PricewaterhouseCoopers, found an average effective tax rate of 27.7 percent among about 500 U.S.-headquartered companies.
That compared with a non-U.S. average effective tax rate of 19.5 percent across on a large selection of countries, from Nigeria to Japan to Qatar, according to the study.
But a lot depends on what countries you are comparing the United States against, and how you crunch the data.
Critics said the study's methods skew the reported U.S. tax rates paid upward.
"The report is hogwash," said Robert McIntyre, director of Citizens for Tax Justice, a consumer group whose own analysis finds companies pay on average rates in the upper teens, after after deductions and loopholes.
Lots of countries have lower effective rates than the United States, including Sweden with a 22 percent rate and smaller countries such as Hungary with a 14 percent rate, according to the study that covered the 2006-2009 period.
Some of the smaller countries only had reports from a handful of companies, while others had hundreds, which can distort the results.
Looking at the Group of Seven industrialized countries, the U.S. rate is on par, according to the study.
For example, Japan has about a 38.8 percent rate, Germany has a 27.9 percent rate and the United Kingdom has a 23.6 percent rate.
McIntyre and a former Treasury official said the study included both current taxes and taxes on income that is deferred, which may never be subject to U.S. tax.
"That makes the U.S. rate look higher than it actually is," McIntyre said.
The Roundtable study computed average effective tax rates paid by dividing total income taxes by pretax income.
The inclusion of deferred taxes also excludes the impact of timing advantages enjoyed by U.S. companies, according to Martin Sullivan, an economist and former U.S. Treasury Department official.
The United States has more liberal depreciation rules than many peers, letting companies more quickly write down the loss in value of equipment and other assets more quickly, .
"The study shows the unsurprising result that compared to multinational companies in other large countries — like Japan, China, Germany, France, United Kingdom — the U.S. book effective rate is marginally higher," Sullivan said. "Taking into account depreciation advantages could significantly change the relative rankings, i.e., the U.S. would almost certainly move down the list."
I Have Just One Question To Ask America's Wealthiest Citizens & The CEOs Of Major U.S. Corporations:
Since You Guys (& Ladies) Are Obviously Receiving The Absolutely BEST Tax Breaks That Anyone Could Ever Desire, Why In The Heck Are You Continuing To Send American Jobs Overseas To Places Like India, Thailand, China, Japan, Indonesia, South America, etc., For Cheap Labor??
As millions of procrastinators scramble to meet Monday's tax filing deadline, ponder this: The super rich pay a lot less taxes than they did a couple of decades ago, and nearly half of U.S. households pay no income taxes at all.
The Internal Revenue Service tracks the tax returns with the 400 highest adjusted gross incomes each year. The average income on those returns in 2007, the latest year for IRS data, was nearly $345 million. Their average federal income tax rate was 17 percent, down from 26 percent in 1992.
Over the same period, the average federal income tax rate for all taxpayers declined to 9.3 percent from 9.9 percent.
The top income tax rate is 35 percent, so how can people who make so much pay so little in taxes? The nation's tax laws are packed with breaks for people at every income level. There are breaks for having children, paying a mortgage, going to college, and even for paying other taxes. Plus, the top rate on capital gains is 15 percent.
There are so many breaks that 45 percent of U.S. households will pay no federal income tax for 2010, according to estimates by the Tax Policy Center, a Washington think tank.
"It's the fact that we are using the tax code both to collect revenue, which is its primary purpose, and to deliver these spending benefits that we run into the situation where so many people are paying no taxes," said Roberton Williams, a senior fellow at the center, which generated the estimate of people who pay no income taxes.
The sheer volume of credits, deductions and exemptions has both Democrats and Republicans calling for tax laws to be overhauled. House Republicans want to eliminate breaks to pay for lower overall rates, reducing the top tax rate from 35 percent to 25 percent. Republicans oppose raising taxes, but they argue that a more efficient tax code would increase economic activity, generating additional tax revenue.
President Barack Obama said last week he wants to do away with tax breaks to lower the rates and to reduce government borrowing. Obama's proposal would result in $1 trillion in tax increases over the next 12 years. Neither proposal included many details, putting off hard choices about which tax breaks to eliminate.
In all, the tax code is filled with a total of $1.1 trillion in credits, deductions and exemptions, an average of about $8,000 per taxpayer, according to an analysis by the National Taxpayer Advocate, an independent watchdog within the IRS.
More than half of the nation's tax revenue came from the top 10 percent of earners in 2007. More than 44 percent came from the top 5 percent. Still, the wealthy have access to much more lucrative tax breaks than people with lower incomes.
More than half of the nation's tax revenue came from the top 10 percent of earners in 2007. More than 44 percent came from the top 5 percent. Still, the wealthy have access to much more lucrative tax breaks than people with lower incomes.
Obama wants the wealthy to pay so "the amount of taxes you pay isn't determined by what kind of accountant you can afford."
Eric Schoenberg says to sign him up for paying higher taxes. Schoenberg, who inherited money and has a healthy portfolio from his days as an investment banker, has joined a group of other wealthy Americans called United for a Fair Economy. Their goal: Raise taxes on rich people like themselves.
Shoenberg, who now teaches a business class at Columbia University, said his income is usually "north of half a million a year." But 2009 was a bad year for investments, so his income dropped to a little over $200,000. His federal income tax bill was a little more than $2,000.
"I simply point out to people, 'Do you think this is reasonable, that somebody in my circumstances should only be paying 1 percent of their income in tax?'" Schoenberg said.
Sen. Orrin Hatch of Utah, the top Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, said he has a solution for rich people who want to pay more in taxes: Write a check to the IRS. There's nothing stopping you.
"There's still time before the filing deadline for them to give Uncle Sam some more money," Hatch said.
Schoenberg said Hatch's suggestion misses the point.
"This voluntary idea clearly represents a mindset that basically pretends there's no such things as collective goods that we produce," Schoenberg said. "Are you going to let people volunteer to build the road system? Are you going to let them volunteer to pay for education?"
The law is packed with tax breaks that help narrow special interests. But many of the biggest tax breaks benefit millions of American families at just about every income level, making them difficult for politicians to touch.
The vast majority of those who escape federal income taxes have low and medium incomes, and most of them pay other taxes, including Social Security and Medicare taxes, property taxes and retail sales taxes.
The share of people paying no federal income tax has dropped slightly the past two years. It was 47 percent for 2009. The main difference for 2010 was the expiration of a tax break that exempted the first $2,400 of unemployment benefits from taxation, Williams said.
In 2009, nearly 35 million taxpayers got a tax break for paying interest on their home mortgages, and nearly 36 million taxpayers took the $1,000-per-child tax credit. About 41 million households reduced their federal income taxes by deducting state and local income and sales taxes from their taxable income.
About 36 million families cut their taxes by nearly $35 billion by deducting charitable donations, and 28 million taxpayers saved a total of $24 billion because their income from Social Security and railroad pensions was untaxed.
"As a matter of policy, there would be a lot of ways to save money and actually make these things work better," said Leonard Burman, a public affairs professor at Syracuse University. "As a matter of politics, it's really, really difficult."
"In a time of great need, when our families and our nation are finding it necessary to tighten our belts, and be more responsible with how we spend our money, we can’t afford to waste taxpayer dollars. And we especially can’t afford to let companies game the system."
N.C. Tax Collectors brought in a Christmas bonus of $427million for the state in December.
That's how much the N.C. Department of Revenue recouped through a program aimed at settling tax disputes with corporations and businesses. The agency estimated it could bring in $150 million when it started the program in August but ended up with an extra $277 million beyond what was factored into the state budget.
"It couldn't have come at a better time," Revenue Secretary Ken Lay said.
The bonus collections will more than wipe out what was a shortfall of $110million at the end of November, compared to projections.
But the good news may not linger. Barry Boardman, the legislature's chief economist, said revenues in December still appear to fall behind what was budgeted.
"I'm not seeing any big turn toward the positive," Boardman said.
The Revenue Department last summer started the corporate tax resolution program. It included waiving penalties for those who settled and 400 corporate taxpayers who were disputing their tax bills. Of those, 300 tried the program, and 236 cases were settled by Dec. 15. Some cases were new; some covered more than a decade.
"We kind of exceeded our wildest dreams," said Linda Millsaps, the department's chief operating officer.
The agency targeted businesses whose disputes involved the state franchise tax, tax reporting for multiple components of the same company and credit card companies contesting how much of their operation was in North Carolina.
Officials said they could not name the corporations involved because state law prohibits departmental disclosure of taxpayer information. Those that chose not to participate remain in the normal dispute resolution process. .
Lay described the negotiations as a business-to-business dialogue in which each side offered its view of the tax debt and the evidence to back it up. A few companies got a tax refund.
The credit card company disputes involved whether the companies maintained enough of a presence in North Carolina to pay state tax, such as offering a credit card in the name of a North Carolina company. Some cases involved the franchise tax, a tax on what a company is worth as opposed to what it makes, and what should be counted toward that value.
Other cases centered on "combined reporting," and whether a company's various appendages can pay taxes separately or whether it has to file as one corporation. Wal-Mart is among the companies that have fought North Carolina in the courts over combined reporting. Officials would not say whether Wal-Mart was among those who settled.
The department did not start out with a grand total of what it thought the companies should pay and bargained down to the $427 million, Lay said. The discussions focused on the method of tax that was in dispute instead of the dollar figure - the rules of the game, rather than the points.
An incentive for the companies was that they didn't just settle a money dispute, they reached an agreement on the guidelines for paying future taxes. The Revenue Department doesn't have to expend the resources to fight legal battles over dozens of tax bills.
"The corporations win," Lay said, "and we win."
Individual taxpayers who don't have a corporation's bullpen of lawyers may wonder why they don't get a chance to settle quarrels over their tax bills.
They do, Lay and Millsaps said. The agency operates several programs that offer individuals the opportunity to settle their tax disputes. The programs typically require that the applicants have a history of paying their taxes.
"I don't know that they're doing anything different (for businesses)," said Elaine Mejia, director of the N.C. Budget & Tax Center, which advocates on behalf of low income families.
Lay said individual taxpayers should not feel they have been "left out in the cold."
As the one-year anniversary of President Obama's inauguration nears, the Tea Party movement is planning a "strike" against corporations they call responsible for "funding socialism" and "backing the leftist agenda" of the new president.
Liberal politicians benefit from "large donors, labor union thugs, Hollywood elites and major media propagating our destruction," contends strike organizer Allen Hardage at the Tea Party Patriots web site.
In the wake of the economic downfall and the financial and auto bailouts of the past year, the tea party movement sprang up to represent conservative voters who felt disenfranchised. The election of a Democratic president intent on promoting new government spending on things like health care has spurred on the movement, prompting protests against big government and its ties to big business.
Hardage writes that on Jan. 20 "the TEA Party movement moves into the next phase, TEA 2.0, of taking our country back... We will demonstrate our power and reach to those companies who employ individuals backing the leftist agenda in every major city, every congressional district and every small rural town in America to spread one unified message. That message is simple: Stop funding socialism."
Hardage told Talking Points Memo that he will not release the companies which the strike will target until Jan. 20. but that it will focus on businesses "that are the largest supporters of the most liberal members of Congress as well as those that support extreme liberal media outlets."
The strike has gained some interest online, where more than 4,000 people have shown their support for the event on Facebook and other sites. If the strike proves ineffective, according to Hardage, the tea partiers will hold a march on Feb. 27, as well as a national boycott "of all of the companies that do not stop donating to people like Harry Reid, Nancy Pelosi, Chris Dodd et al."
Republicans have tried to capture the energy of the tea partiers. GOP Rep. Michele Bachmann said in a radio interview on Dec. 29 that if the Republican party wants to succeed in the 2010 midterm elections, it needs to "embrace the tea party movement with full arms."
But Suzy Khimm of Newsweek points out that the movement "has yet to pay off for the Republican Party in terms of small-scale donations─the kind of grassroots support that proved critical to bringing Obama and congressional Democrats to power last year."
Up-and-coming conservative politicians like Marco Rubio in Florida, however, could try to bring tea partiers into the Republican fold as he battles Gov. Charlie Crist in a GOP Senate primary this year. If the tea partiers succeed in electing politicians like Rubio, New York Times columnist David Brooks writes, "their movement is likely to outgrow its crude beginnings and become a major force in American politics."
Cash-strapped communities have a message for corporations that promised jobs in return for tax breaks: A deal's a deal.
As the economy sputters along, municipalities struggling to fix roads, fund schools and pay bills increasingly are rescinding tax abatements to companies that don't hire enough workers, that lay them off or that close up shop. At the same time, they're sharpening new incentive deals, leaving no doubt what is expected of companies and what will happen if they don't deliver.
''We will roll out the red carpet as much as we can (but) they are going to honor the contract,'' said Brendon Gallagher, an alderman in DeKalb, Ill., where Target Corp. got abatements from the city, county, school district and other taxing bodies after promising at least 500 jobs at a local distribution center.
So when the company came up 66 workers short in 2009, Target got word its next tax bill would be jumping almost $600,000 -- more than half of which goes to the local school district, where teachers and programs have been cut as coffers dried up.
The newfound boldness comes from communities and states that have long bent over backward to lure companies and jobs by offering abatements and other incentives -- to the tune of an estimated $60 billion a year in the United States, according to the Washington-based economic development watchdog group Good Jobs First.
The willingness to write -- and enforce -- the ''clawback'' provisions comes even as companies across the country struggle and against a broader backdrop of governments getting tough on business practices.
What's more, the poor economy has communities thinking about how the tax breaks they dole out will play with residents who have grown increasingly angry at the thought of anything that hints of corporate welfare.
''The public is a lot more aware of tax abatements and there's a climate of skepticism about what can be perceived as corporate handouts,'' said Geoff McKimm, a member of the Monroe County Council in Indiana.
With that in mind, county officials drew up an agreement with Printpack, a packaging company, that includes a provision requiring the company to refund either $197,000 or that year's abatement, whichever is more, if the number of employees at a new factory falls below 140.
Another provision requires Printpack to refund the entire abatement if it employs fewer than 75 people -- a guarantee meant to prevent companies from leaving a ''skeleton crew'' at a location to avoid paying up.
''With so many businesses going to Mexico, communities are desperately trying to hold onto jobs,'' said Amy Gerstman, the county's auditor. ''This was a carefully put-together abatement.''
And businesses increasingly are being forced to hold up their end of the bargain.
In Texas, where companies can get money from the Texas Enterprise Fund if they promise to create a specific number of jobs, the number of clawbacks rose to nine in 2008, compared to a total of seven for the previous three years combined, the governor's office said.
In Illinois, the number of companies from which the state sought to ''recapture'' incentive money has steadily climbed, from six in 2005 to a total of 37 by 2008.
Meanwhile, more communities are contemplating similar action.
In St. Louis County, officials have told Pfizer Inc. that if it cuts 600 jobs, as planned, they'll rethink the $7 million in tax breaks they promised to give the drugmaker for the next 10 years.
And in Detroit, while the state was approving expanded tax credits in exchange for General Motors Co.'s promise not to move its headquarters, the city council was talking about cracking down on tax breaks for GM and other major employers.
''We know that there are more clawbacks getting triggered because more deals are falling short,'' said Greg LeRoy, executive director of Good Jobs First, who has written extensively on clawbacks.
It's unclear exactly how much is being recovered because nobody collects comprehensive statistics on clawbacks, LeRoy and others say. States that do keep statistics track only their own deals, not those initiated by local governments. Communities also may revoke the entire abatement or only a portion of it, while others sometimes simply rule out future abatements, LeRoy said.
Finally, some communities crack down on companies quietly, out of concern that they could scare off other potential employers, LeRoy said. He said that fear persists even though there is no evidence that having or enforcing clawbacks poisons the business climate.
''We were told that we were going to ruin Topeka's ability to attract businesses; we'd give Topeka a black eye,'' said James Crowl, assistant county counselor in Shawnee County, where last year officials approved a settlement that calls for Target to pay $200,000 a year for 10 years after failing to create as many jobs as it had agreed to.
So what happened?
''Last year we opened a Home Depot distribution center right next door,'' said County Counselor Rich Eckert.
In DeKalb, some officials were concerned about sending a bad message to other businesses considering locating there, said Gallagher, the alderman. But he didn't buy it.
''We are 65 miles from Chicago (and) if someone wants to locate 120 miles from Chicago, I can't stop them,'' he said.
Besides, he said, $600,000 means less to Target than to a struggling community, where he said the city alone is facing a $2 million revenue shortfall.
Target was disappointed, but understood the decision, spokeswoman Jill Hornbacher said.
''We are very committed to DeKalb and that distribution center and proud to be there,'' she said.
And don't expect communities to back down soon, officials said.
''There is much more (language) tied to jobs now because of economy,'' said Lee Garrity, city manager in Winston-Salem, N.C., which along with the surrounding county is sharing more than $26 million that computer giant Dell Inc. paid after announcing it will close its assembly plant next year.
Garrity said officials are thinking about provisions that are even more specific.
''We are discussing whether we need to require the jobs of the company go to people who live in the city,'' he said.
A pair of specialty outsourcing companies won't collect job-creation grants from North Carolina taxpayers as the recession hits health care and financial services differently.
The state's Economic Investment Committee, which awards and oversees the major incentives program used to lure expanding companies, on Tuesday canceled a 2005 deal with Hewitt Associates Inc. The Lincolnshire, Ill.-based company had planned to bring 900 new jobs to Charlotte. Those human resources administration and information technology positions didn't happen as the global financial crisis hit the banking city hard.
But two years of recession hasn't slowed the expansion of Durham-based Quintiles Transnational Corp.
The global pharmaceutical testing firm decided to postpone collecting a Job Development Investment Grant payment of $299,000 in a gesture to help out the cash-strapped state budget, an offer the committee accepted Tuesday.
The company will defer collecting the money until the middle of next year, about when the state's budget for the current year closes out.
"Quintiles has been very fortunate that we have performed well and even in this downturn we have seen expansion in our business," spokesman Phil Bridges said. "We recognize that the current economy has put the state of North Carolina in a tough financial position. Quintiles made the offer to defer payment on the (grant) as a way of saying thank you, not only for investing in us but believing in us and our future growth in North Carolina."
Quintiles could receive up to $21.4 million over 12 years under a grant awarded in 2006 to create and sustain 1,000 new jobs. The grants come from taxes the company's employees pay the state.
Since 2006, the contract drug research company has spent $51 million to build a new headquarters and hired nearly 400 workers at salaries averaging nearly $81,000 a year.
Quintiles runs clinical drug trials for pharmaceutical companies, handles documentation necessary for regulatory approval, and recruits and hires drug company sales representatives.
Hewitt met its target to create at least 158 new jobs by the end of 2006 and was due to collect $181,000, a figure the state Commerce Department couldn't and Hewitt wouldn't confirm Tuesday.
But the global provider of human resources support and consulting services wasn't able to hire at least 630 additional employees by the end of 2008 or hit its target of 900 jobs by the end of this year.
Hewitt could have collected up to $8 million if it created the jobs and kept them for 10 years.
The company is the 14th to quit the JDIG program out of 100 approved for job-creation sweeteners since the program started in 2003.
Boat builder Chris-Craft Corp., computer builders Dell Inc. and Lenovo, and memory-chip maker Qimonda North American decided in recent years to cut staff rather than expand as their sales soured, ending their claims on promised incentives. After opening a $600 million data center near Lenoir, Internet giant Google last year turned down the grant it was promised in 2006.
Hewitt restructured its human resources business process outsourcing business in 2006, then was set back as some clients suffered when the financial crisis hit, Hewitt spokeswoman Amy Wulfestieg said. The company employs about 450 in Charlotte, she said.
Despite winning more than $300 million in incentives and tax breaks from North Carolina and local governments four years ago, Dell Inc. has decided to shutter an assembly plant because of changing economic circumstances.
This fall Dell announced it would close the plant and lay off more than 900 employees. Company officials say they expect the shutdown to be completed in January.
In 2004 the North Carolina General Assembly was called into a special one-day session by then-Governor Mike Easley (D) to offer Dell $240 million of economic incentives to build a manufacturing facility. Coupled with what Forsyth County and the city of Winston-Salem added, the deal came to more than $300 million in tax breaks and benefits.
Rushed Package
During the special one-day session in 2004, Governor Easley’s senior advisor, Dan Gerlach, argued legislators needed to act quickly to prevent other states from getting the facility. The lawmakers did, and the state put together a complex assortment of incentives, grants, and tax breaks.
With layoffs already ongoing and Dell’s prospects worsening in July of this year, Department of Commerce officials continued supporting the deal. Secretary Keith Crisco told reporters, “We need three to four years to judge it in total. [Dell is] the kind of company we need to be all over [recruiting] in this state.”
With Dell’s plant closure, some critics are pushing for more broad-based approaches to corporate recruitment. Representative Marilyn Avila (R-Wake) thinks targeted tax incentives miss the point.
Simple Solution
“We should develop a statewide economic development plan, which is simply lowering corporate taxes,” she said.
Avila has long argued the state’s tax structure and regulations hinder job creation. She believes the use of incentives should be stopped.
Governor Bev Perdue (D), however, still equates such incentives with job creation.
“When 49 other states are using incentives, if you want to compete [you have to as well,” Perdue said in an interview with WRAL-TV in Raleigh.
Speaker of the House Joe Hackney (D-Orange) pointed out Dell did not use all the available money.
"While the bottom line is still being calculated, either we didn't lose money or we had a net gain in revenues for the state," he said.
Lawsuits Likely
Hackney’s comments illustrate another dimension of the state’s incentive policies. The complexity and myriad performance measures mean disputes between Dell and the state over money owed or needed to be repaid will likely end up in court at taxpayer expense.
Dell spokesman David Frink said recently in the Winston-Salem Journal, “Our belief and our understanding is that we met the performance thresholds required for those incentives during those years, and no, we are not obliged to repay those.”
North Carolina officials hold the opposite view. State Revenue Secretary Ken Lay says the state can require Dell to pay back the money because it no longer meets criteria used to receive it. He calls such a move a “look back.”
Half the Promised Jobs
Public officials promised taxpayers this deal would not lose money for the state. In spite of the much-publicized promise of more than 2000 jobs, the Dell facility never produced more than 1,100 jobs and still received millions of dollars from the state.
If it can be proven the state lost any money, public officials might well have serious problems on their hands from voters and legal challenges from groups like the NC Institute of Constitutional Law, which has challenged many of the state’s targeted tax incentives.
Former North Carolina Supreme Court Justice Robert Orr runs the NC Institute of Constitutional Law. In a letter to the Charlotte News-Observer newspaper, he wrote: “It's very tempting to think that economic development can happen by granting a few companies exceptions to a state's otherwise unattractive tax code. But it doesn't work that way. States should be welcome mats to all business, not just those the politicians have picked as a winner.”
Democrats anxious about high unemployment have shifted gears and are poised to expand a stimulus provision that would quickly put $33 billion in the pockets of businesses.
The Senate on Wednesday approved a tax break that allows firms to carry back losses to get refunds on taxes paid over the past five years, and the House is expected to follow. The tax provision is packaged with a bill extending unemployment benefits.
Business groups had pushed for the five-year carry-back provision during the debate over the 2008 stimulus bill signed by President George W. Bush, but were blocked by House Democrats who argued it would have helped businesses more than individuals.
Now, with unemployment expected to hit 10 percent this fall and possibly as early as Friday’s jobs report, Democrats have embraced the provision as a way to spark employment ahead of next year’s elections.
A five-year carry-back “is one of the very few ways in the tax system you can actually put cash into the hands of business very quickly,” said Clint Stretch, director of tax policy at Deloitte & Touche.
In an interview, Rep. Richard Neal (D-Mass.), a senior member of the House Ways and Means Committee, cast the provision as an economic tool that should be used immediately.
He acknowledged that a number of businesses, including real estate agencies, bankers and retailers, will benefit from the tax break, but he said that it would also help individuals because it would prevent layoffs.
“It might not be a job creator, but it will save an awful lot of jobs,” Neal said.
House Democratic leaders plan to take up the package including the carryover provision the Senate passed Wednesday, Neal said.
Businesses may already carry back losses for two years. The $787 billion economic stimulus bill approved earlier this year expanded that provision to allow small businesses with less than $15 million in gross receipts to get refunds on profits from the past five years.
Under the measure written by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) and Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus (D-Mont.), all businesses would get carry-back for five years.
The Joint Committee on Taxation said that the broader carry-back provision would save businesses $33 billion in 2010 and would cost the government $10.4 billion over the next decade.
The carry-back expansion along with a tax credit for homebuyers will be paid for by delaying by seven years another tax break for U.S.-based international corporations that was scheduled to start in 2010.
Neal noted that White House economists Lawrence Summers and Jason Furman offered support for the plan this week when he spoke with them. The Obama administration included an expanded carryover provision in its budget proposal.
Still, some liberal lawmakers remain uneasy over broadening the tax provision. Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-Ore.) said that it’s not as critical as extending unemployment benefits that directly help out-of-work Americans.
“Things like the operating loss provision actually are slightly different,” Blumenauer said. “That just shifts revenue.”
The carryover won’t serve as stimulus and will only give more money to businesses, said liberal economist Dean Baker, the co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research.
“It will have almost no impact on investment or employment,” Baker said. “It would be hard to think of expenditures that will have less impact on the economy.”
Business groups ramped up their campaign for a broader tax break after this year’s stimulus only provided the benefit to smaller businesses.
Homebuilders had been among the first to push for the tax provision, but a broader range of manufacturers, Realtors, restaurants, newspapers and other business interests took up the campaign in the late winter and spring. Lobbyists sent a letter to congressional lawmakers in April that was signed by more than 80 CEOs, and they held more than 100 fly-ins with tax executives and CEOs.
That helped lobbyists round up congressional supporters for the broader provision.
Support has been building steadily.
When a standalone carry-back bill was introduced in the House in May, it had five co-sponsors. The measure now has more than 180 co-sponsors. A companion bill started in the Senate with seven co-sponsors; it now has wide bipartisan backing from more than 44 senators.
House Republicans called for a five-year carry-back provision, among other stimulus measures, in a letter to President Barack Obama last month. Soon after, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said that the carry-back idea “has some currency.”
Welcome to the BLACK POLITICAL BUZZ Blog. (Established 2008)
My name is Laurel. (Author & Publisher)
I Blog with a focus on POLITICS, Business, and occasionally Entertainment.
FACTS ABOUT LAUREL:
Wife,
Mother of a U.S. Soldier,
Sister,
Woman of GOD,
Loyal Friend,
Creative,
Blood-related to a nationally known Charlotte Politician.
Black Female, Intelligent,
Married,
Love to Travel,
Credentialed by the RNC and DNC.
Political Blogger/ Commentator
Grassroots Activist,
PROFESSIONAL STATUS:
Credential Political Blogger/ Commentator,
Registered Independent Voter
Original Native of BROOKLYN, NY
Currently reside in CHARLOTTE, NC
I’m Nice but don’t get it twisted because my Mind is Sharp!
Since You’ve Chosen to Visit and Read the Contents of this Blog by Personal Choice, and of Your Own Free Will,
Please don’t ask me to Compensate you for Expressing individual commentary/ Posted Articles, which are protected by the First Amendment, citing Freedom of Speech & Freedom of Expression.
No Intentionally Malicious Slander, Libel or Defamation of Character content will be published and I will always Credit all Sources.
NOTE TO ALL ELECTED OFFICIALS, APPOINTED OFFICIALS & PUBLIC FIGURES:
Per the Landmark U.S. Supreme Court Case: 1964 case of New York Times v. Sullivan………
The Public has a Right to Criticize the People who Govern them, so the least Protection from Defamation is given to Public Officials. When officials are accused of something that involves their behavior in office, they have to prove all of the above elements of defamation and they must also prove that the defendant acted with “actual malice.” (For a definition of actual malice, see the “History of Defamation and the First Amendment, below.”)
People who aren’t Elected but who are Still Public Figures because they are influential or famous — like Actors, Actresses, Movie Stars, Singers & Entertainers, Journalists, TV Hosts, Bloggers, etc., — also have to Prove that Defamatory statements were made with Actual Malice, in most cases.
To the Associated Press and other Media Organizations:
When I use your Content Links., I’m also citing the Fair Use Doctrine (Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107) for further Copyright permission.
Posts and Links published on Black Political Buzz are not endorsed by Black Political Buzz Blog Author Laurel’s Employer, nor the Employers of other Black Political Buzz employees.
This includes Links, Posts and Comments posted on Black Political Buzz’s Facebook and Twitter account pages.
Comments, Links and Opinions of site visitors are Independently-Owned and not endorsed by Black Political Buzz employees, Blog Author Laurel or Laurel’s Employer.)
(No Personal Offense intended) Please know that Black Political Buzz is not responsible for nor do I endorse Requests for Donations from Third Parties on this Blog.
I will Only Endorse Requests for Donations made on behalf of BLACK POLITICAL BUZZ Blog for Business Purposes & Operating Expenses.
I will also Only Endorse Requests for Donations on behalf of Legitimate Politicians and Legitimate Political Candidates. PERIOD!!
If anyone else or another Organization wishes to post a link to Request Donations, I am NOT endorsing ANY of those Requests!
Unless I receive a personal Request to do so and I have Professionally Confirmed that the Third Party Organization or Charity is indeed a Legitimate Entity.
NOTE: Anyone who chooses to give to any Third Party Organization NOT Endorsed by BLACK POLITICAL BUZZ is doing so at his or her own risk.
BLACK POLITICAL BUZZ does NOT Discriminate against Politicians, Political Candidates, Organizations or Charities based on Race, Color, Nationality, Ethnicity, Gender, Sexual Orientation, Religion, Faith, Disability, Political Affiliation, Creed, Education, Social Status, Age.
This disclaimer applies to ANY and All requests for Donations on this Blog. Thanks for understanding. Again No Personal Offense intended.
For Story Tips….Corrections…….. or Requests for Endorsements:
Please contact me via e-mail: blackpoliticalbuzz@gmail.com
or via my Facebook page: facebook.com/blackpoliticalbuzz
Thanks for stopping by
God Bless
Laurel @BLACK POLITICAL BUZZ
LINKS: POLITICAL PERSPECTIVE & INFORMATIONAL SITES